Bush abandons partisanship for empathy

|

Analysis:

This story is based upon President Bush's Veteran's Day speech in Waco, Texas. Bush addressed military veterans and military families. The only people cited in the story are Bush--who speaks to the loss of US soldiers--and White House spokesperson Gordon Johndroe. Johndroe states that Bush originally was going to attack the Democrats for not "approving the Veterans Affairs appropriation." The article makes nomention of what the Veterans Affairs appropriation is, nor why the Democrats haven't approved it. The partisan issue is what is highlighted in the headline, but does the story focus on that aspect? Why are there no veteran voices in this story and would have it been useful for readers to get an overview of what kind of support the Bush administration has been providing to veterans and their familes while in office?

Story:

In the simple hall -- linoleum floor, white cinder-block walls -- that is home to American Legion Post 121, President Bush on Sunday told the families of two soldiers and two Marines who died in Iraq that "their sacrifice will not be in vain."

His brief message on Veterans Day was one that finds its way regularly into his speeches about the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, and in his now-frequent private meetings with families of the wars' casualties.

But on Sunday, his part in the ceremony, a six-minute speech, suggested an afterthought -- after four mayors awkwardly read the stilted language of memorial resolutions, after the presentation of Lone Star flags that had flown over the Capitol in Austin, Texas, and after "gold star" banners were handed to mothers and widows.

Bush sat through it all -- the recounting, one by one, of the lives and the losses -- and by the time he was called to speak before about 200 people, he abandoned what had been planned as the political focus of his remarks: an attack on Democrats for not yet approving the Veterans Affairs appropriation.

"He felt it was more appropriate to shorten his remarks," White House spokesman Gordon D. Johndroe said.

Bush was seated in the second row; parents and widows were in the first. He sat next to Janie Shanks, grandmother of Marine Gunnery Sgt. John David Fry, who was 28 when he died in Iraq on March 8, 2006.

On one mission, Fry, the father of three children, entered a home to disarm an improvised bomb strapped to a retarded child, said Democratic Rep. Chet Edwards, whose congressional district includes Waco.

Days before his tour was to end, Fry volunteered for another mission to defuse a bomb , Edwards said. That one killed him.

On Sunday, there was an elderly bugler in a yellow cap, white gloves grasping his horn as he blew taps. A local woman, Ann Harder, sang "God Bless America" a cappella and solo, until she paused, said, "Sing with me," and 200 voices joined in.

The post commander, Clayton Hueske, admitted he was nervous and stumbled over his words; another speaker gave the audience permission to cry.

Some speakers, but not all, were dressed in jacket and tie. In the audience were leather motorcycle vests, a white shirt with an American flag, a red 2004 state high school football championship T-shirt -- and, throughout, the quiet sound of sniffling.

"The young men we remember today did not live to be called veterans," Bush said in his speech. "The valor and selfless devotion of these men fills their families with immeasurable pride. Yet this pride cannot fill the hole in their loved ones' aching hearts, or relieve the burden of grief that will remain for a lifetime.

"In their sorrow," he said, "these families need to know, and families all across the nation of the fallen need to know, that your loved ones served a cause that is good, and just, and noble."

Email Updates

Subscribe

Receive our articles automatically:

Donate

Media Mouse is reader funded and relies on contributions to provide unique reporting and research.

donate

Bloom Collective

bloom collective logo

Media Mouse is part of the Bloom Collective, an infoshop and lending library located at 1134 Wealthy St SE. The Bloom Collective offers a wide variety of resources to promote social change.

Promote Mediamouse.org

You can help promote Mediamouse.org by printing and distributing flyers or by adding us as a friend on the following social networks:

grand rapids institute for information democracy

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Media Mouse published on November 12, 2007 1:28 PM.

Don't Bother: No need for edict on Iran policy was the previous entry in this blog.

Lowering standards to meet recruitment numbers is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

About Mediamouse.org

Mediamouse.org is a left and progressive website providing independent news, media, analysis, and commentary covering Grand Rapids, Michigan and beyond. We aim to inspire grassroots activism to transform our community, our lives, and our world.

Get Active

We hope that this site will function as a catalyst for action. We urge you to get involved either with the groups listed in the Progressive Directory or by attending local events.