Tag Archives: hate crimes

West Michigan Legislator Announces New Effort to Increase Penalties for Church Disruption

Dave Agema Has Launched a New Effort to Increase Penalties for Disrupting Church Services; Perhaps Motivated by Anti-Gay Politics

Grand Rapids area Representative Dave Agema has launched a new effort to increase penalties for disrupting a church service in response to a protest last year by a gay activist group that targeted an church in Lansing known for its involvement in anti-gay politics.

According to The Grand Rapids Press online:

In response to a pro-gay group charging into an evangelical church near Lansing and shouting “Jesus was a homo,” and “It’s OK to be gay,” a Grandville lawmaker proposed a bill to hike penalties for disruptions of religious services.

Republican state Rep. Dave Agema’s legislation increases the penalty for disruption of a religious service to a $5,000 fine.

“This disruptive behavior is not appropriate or acceptable anywhere, and not in places of worship,” said Agema in a news release. “Religious freedom is a basic American right and it must be protected by increasing the penalty to deter those who would obstruct and endanger other people’s rights in a church with their excessive demonstration.”

Anti-Gay Motivation?

Reading this, you’ve really got to ask yourself whether it has to do with the act of disrupting the church service itself, or Agema’s own anti-gay politics. In the past, he’s proposed measures that would cut funding for university’s–including West Michigan’s Grand Valley State University (GVSU)–that offer domestic partner benefits.

Why didn’t he pursue this last term, following well-publicized efforts by anti-gay protestors to disrupt funeral services? Granted, that happened before he was elected, but if this was really such a serious issue for him you’d think he would have pursued it.

Furthermore, is this not proposing an unnecessary law–such behavior is already illegal and constitutes a variety of charges? In the past, Agema has been a staunch opponent of “hate crimes” legislation in part because he argues that those crimes are already illegal under existing law.

Rise in Hate Crimes against Latinos Coincides with Rise in Anti-Immigrant Rhetoric

When the Federal Bureau of Investigations (FBI) released its 2006 hate crime statistics last week, there was a trend that did not receive much attention in the media–an increase in hate crimes directed at Latinos. While reminding readers that hate crimes statistics are highly unreliable, the Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) has pointed out that hate crimes against Latinos have grown by 35% from 2003 to 2006. In California, where there is the largest Latino population in the United States, the crimes have doubled.

The SPLC links this increase in anti-immigrant rhetoric in recent years, much of which has sought to dehumanize Latinos as “invaders,” “criminals,” or “cockroaches.” According to the Center, “the perpetrators range from racist skinheads to rogue Border Patrol agents to otherwise everyday citizens.”

Michigan Ranked 3rd in Hate Crimes

For the third year in a row, the Federal Bureau of Investigations (FBI) ranks Michigan third in the United States for the number of hate crimes. Michigan reported 653 hate crimes in 2006, placing it behind California (1,297) and New Jersey (759). While part of Michigan’s ranking may be due to the fact that it does a better job reporting hate crimes than many other states, an official with the Michigan Department of Civil Rights quoted in the State News said that the number is related to a rise in neo-Nazi/Ku Klux Klan groups in Michigan combined with longstanding patterns of segregation. Seventy-five percent of the hate crimes reported in Michigan were racial in nature. In Grand Rapids, thirty-five hate crimes were reported, twenty-six of which were racial in nature (four were based on sexual orientation).

The FBI defines a hate crime as:

“…a criminal offense committed against a person, property, or society that is motivated, in whole or in part, by the offender’s bias against a race, religion, disability, sexual orientation, or ethnicity/national origin.”

Grand Rapids Attack a Hate Crime

The Grand Rapids Press reported today that the Michigan Civil Rights Commission has condemned the weekend attack on 34-year old Hai Vo as a hate crime. According to media reports, Vo—who was standing across the street while waiting for his sister to pick him was attacked outside of The BOB nightclub in downtown Grand Rapids after a fight broke out between two groups after someone in one white group made a comment that “Asian women could be sold for $5. The Michigan Civil Rights Commission stated that it “condemns all acts of hate” and called on the Grand Rapids community to “speak out against hatred and intolerance and defend the cause of racial diversity” while it completes an investigation into the incident.

Unfortunately, hate crimes continue to be committed in the Grand Rapids area and reflect the role that pervasive racism, heterosexism, and patriarchal thinking have in shaping how people in this city relate to each other. Persistent reports of hate crimes have come from Grand Valley State University where there were 17 hate crimes—including racist graffiti and a homosexual couple being spat on—reported between July 2005 to April of 2006 while there were a total of 54 hate crimes reported in Grand Rapids in 2005. Reporting in the local media failed to put Sunday’s incident into its proper context, leaving out not only the prevalence of such crimes in West Michigan, but also the fact that hate crimes towards Asian Americans and the GBLT community are growing according to the FBI, and that there has been an increase in organized racist groups in West Michigan. Moreover, the media’s coverage failed to examine institutional racism and the ways in which the very structures of this society—from the prison system to the educational system—neglect or oppress people of color, creating a context in which racist thinking continues to be the norm.

Hundreds Protest Neo-Nazi National Socialist Movement in Lansing

photo from lansing nazi protest

Hundreds of protestors outnumbered the neo-Nazi National Socialist Movement (NSM) at their national rally on Saturday in Lansing. Before the event, the NSM claimed that they would have over 200 members and supporters in attendance, however, the group mustered well less than 80 members with fewer than 10 supporters for their rally which lasted from about 2:15pm to 4:00pm on the steps of the capitol building. Protestors, who were separated in two groups due to a decision made by some protestors to stay out of the “protest pens” designated by the police, numbered between 600 and 800 according to eyewitness and media accounts.

The protest organized by the Lansing Coalition Against Nazis (LCAN) began at 12:30pm in Riverfront Park at the corner of Michigan and Grand with a couple brief speeches leading up to a march that left at 1:00pm. The march, which consisted of a couple of hundred people, was quite energetic with drums, several large banners featuring anti-Nazi slogans (“No Nazis, No MCRI [Michigan Civil Rights Initiative],” “No Nazis, No KKK, No Fascist USA,” “Hate Speech Leads to Hate Crime,” “Nazis Not Welcome”) and several chants led by both march organizers and by people within the crowd. The march ended at the corner of Washington and Michigan where the group initially moved towards one of the security checkpoints and then moved back once it seemed that the police were maneuvering to contain the march. The march, after a brief confrontation with one Nazi supporter that resulted in one arrest, eventually settled at this spot for what essentially was a rally held outside the protest in an attempt to setup a “noise blockade” against the Nazis. It is hard to measure the effectiveness of the noise blockade because protest participants were unable to hear the Nazis but there were reports from arrested protestors that they could hear the Nazis while in jail (the jail was located right next to the crowd). The crowd’s energy was kept high with chants such as “Fuck the Aryan Nation,” “No Nazis, No KKK, No Fascist Us,” “Hey Nazis, What’s Up, What’s Up, You’ve Come to our Town and we’re going to Fuck you Up,” “Cops and Klan, Hand in Hand,” and “Up, Up with the People, and Down, Down, with the Nazis.” Throughout this rally, the cops moved into arrest people wearing bandanas or to confiscate banners and other supplies in several small police-initiated scuffles. Short impromptu speeches also addressed the obligation of people to work in the communities that the Nazis are targeting—primarily those who have been victimized by global capitalism and who have been targeted by the Nazis’ rhetoric of scapegoating.

Following the end of the Nazis rally, several protestors who were inside of the designated protest pen (some of whom toppled the fence designed to protect the Nazis) joined up with the LCAN sponsored protest and began rapidly marching through the streets near the capitol building in search of Nazis or their supporters. The march frequently turned in to a running group with several people surging ahead to confront Nazi supporters, many of whom were spit on, hit with construction fences, punched, or hit with rocks before people were able to move in to protect the Nazi supporters and disperse protestors. During these scuffles a police van got its window smashed after the police used it to shelter a beaten Nazi supporter, prompting mounted and riot police to move in to push the group east of Washington. The group decided to march towards Eastern High School to join the city sponsored “Diversity Rally” in an unpermitted march that stopped traffic along Shiawassee and garnered a show of support from community members along the route. As the group approached the Diversity Rally, the police positioned several dozen riot police armed with rubber bullet guns, tear gas, and batons in order to prevent the marchers from joining up with the rally. In the days before the rally, the police and city said they would allow the Nazis to attend the Diversity Rally but they restricted protestors demonstrating against the Nazis from entering and later portrayed the group as a “mob” in the media. After the group was denied access to the Diversity Rally it marched to intersection of Michigan and Grand, where the several dozen riot police and state police moved in and an order was given to disperse from the park or be arrested. Protestors dispersed at that point because there was nothing to be gained by continuing the protest.

The corporate media, which spent several weeks both in Lansing and in Michigan as a whole focusing on security preparations, largely focused their post-rally coverage on how the police prevented violence and kept “order” during the protest. Even in light of the physical attacks on at least three Nazi supporters, the media stuck to this line and downplayed the arrests of sixteen protestors, instead choosing to emphasize the success of the preparations of state and local police. While all media reports on the rally prominently featured the protests, it was rare that they did so in any substantive manner, instead choosing to quote people who discussed the need to come out and show “love” in the face of hate. In the same manner that media failed to fully engage the reasons why groups organized against the Nazis, media reports also failed to engage the substance of Nazism and instead reported on the Nazis as if they were just another political party or group in United States and not a movement based on an ideology responsible for the deaths of some six million people in concentration camps. The corporate media described how the NSM promised that they would “close the borders” because “the people” allegedly want the borders closed and that the NSM will participate in upcoming elections in the United States. The reporting largely ignored the NSM’s racism, despite the fact that racism is the crux of their ideology and political movement.

The NSM has announced that it plans further rallies and activities in Michigan. The NSM initially expressed considerable frustration with the way the rally went, citing the fact that the strict security allegedly kept away their supporters, that the media underplayed their numbers, and that multiple supporters were physically beaten leaving the rally. The NSM plans to hold an organizational meeting for new members in Lansing within the next two weeks, citing what they termed an “amazing” response with three-dozen inquiries coming from Michigan residents. Earlier in the week, anti-racist and anti-fascist activists protested the NSM in Grand Rapids and exposed Ken Mathews, a Grand Rapids resident who leads the Southeast Michigan Unit of the NSM. The Michigan NSM, termed “Unit Hitler” by the NSM’s spokesperson Bill White was given a “Unit Award” for its rapid growth and its contributions to the Nazi movement.

Photos from the protest